Historian Says Slavery-Era Law Shapes Policing Today

Georgetown's November 17 talk drew on the 1850 Fugitive Slave Act, a rule that deputized citizens to help capture runaways.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a columned civic facade casting a long shadow across an empty plaza, with a partly open iron gate, in deep red, cream, and charcoal.
Georgetown historian Gautham Rao argued at a November 17 event that the 1850 Fugitive Slave Act's deputization rules still shape American policing and immigration enforcement today. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think the U.S. justice system treats people of all races fairly?

Washington residents working in or studying the justice system heard Georgetown University historian Gautham Rao argue on November 17 that slavery-era law still shapes policing today. Rao presented the case at a Georgetown event hosted by the Racial Justice Institute and the Prisons and Justice Initiative.

Why it matters

For a city where federal law enforcement is a daily presence, Rao's argument traces today's policing and immigration enforcement back to rules built to catch people who had escaped slavery. The debate over whether those roots still matter is open, and Rao's projections about accountability, including qualified immunity, remain positions he advanced rather than settled outcomes.

The key historical figure is 1850, when the Fugitive Slave Act nationalized the deputization of citizens and law enforcement to capture runaway enslaved people, with penalties for noncompliance. The record Rao cites is a historical legal one, and the extraction does not give current local enforcement statistics for comparison.

The players

Gautham Rao

A professor at American University and editor-in-chief of Law and History Review, who argues slavery-era laws still influence the U.S. justice system.

Georgetown University

The Washington university that hosted the November 17 event, organized with its Racial Justice Institute and Prisons and Justice Initiative.

The details

At the November 17 Georgetown University event, hosted by the Racial Justice Institute and the Prisons and Justice Initiative, Rao described deputization as law enforcement making decisions for detainees they believe need additional support. He traced that principle through southern county, parish and state laws before the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 nationalized it, and he cited a 17th-century Virginia case in which a Black runaway servant was made a servant for life while white servants received extended indentures. Rao, a professor at American University and editor-in-chief of Law and History Review, laid out these arguments in his book White Power: Policing American Slavery.

Timeline

  1. 1850: Fugitive Slave Act enacted, nationalizing the deputization of slave capture.

  2. Nov. 17: Rao presents his arguments at the Georgetown University event.

  3. Jan. 6: The Capitol riot following Trump's 2020 election loss, which Rao cited in discussing a possible reckoning.

The District View

Washington sits in a city whose federal presence has long made policing and federal authority a local question, and Rao's argument reaches back to the 1850 act that nationalized citizen deputization. The extraction offers no direct local comparison, so the connection to the District is one of historical framing rather than a documented local trend.

If you work in policing, immigration enforcement or the courts here, Rao's argument is a prompt to look at how deputization and qualified immunity are used today. Residents who want to follow the debate can attend future public events at Georgetown's Racial Justice Institute and Prisons and Justice Initiative.

The takeaway

Rao's point is that the rules for catching people who escape control have deep roots, and those roots still shape how enforcement works. Watch how courts and policymakers address qualified immunity and deputization, since Rao called curtailing qualified immunity a huge practical step.

Further reading

For more on how the Metropolitan Police Department and federal agencies share the city's policing work, see Law Enforcement coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Hoya.

Live Poll

Do you think the U.S. justice system treats people of all races fairly?